KSCA attends Solar Action Summit at Westminster

Tony Day and Simon Chandler represented Kingsway Solar Community Action (KSCA) and the Parish Council Alliance at the Solar Action Summit, held at Portcullis House, Westminster, on 26 October 2026.

KSCA attends Solar Action Summit at Westminster

Convened by Dr Caroline Johnson MP, the summit brought together representatives from 20 campaign groups challenging very large-scale, ground-mounted solar developments across England, from Devon to Yorkshire and Kent. The event included presentations from MPs, campaign groups, researchers and CPRE, followed by a question-and-answer session.

The aim was to explore how pressure could be brought to bear on ministers to change government policy on large-scale ground-mounted solar. Speakers discussed the impacts of current proposals and possible ways to influence the Government’s direction. The need for a collective approach was emphasised, including the formation of a new campaign, Sensible Solar.

Dr Johnson highlighted the growing number of large solar developments. More than 6,000 hectares had been consented in the two years since Labour came to power, double the amount in the previous ten years. She also noted that solar developments in her Lincolnshire constituency totalled 11,000 acres.

Dr Johnson stressed the importance of cross-party involvement. All MPs had been invited, including the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, who was unable to attend. Andrew Bowie, the Shadow Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, was present, but Pippa Heylings, the Liberal Democrat spokesperson for Energy Security and Net Zero, was unable to attend. Dr Johnson also noted that attendance at parliamentary debates on solar developments had increased, with many MPs unable to secure speaking time at the most recent debate.

The impact on communities

Stephen Boulton from Stop Beacon Solar in North Devon described how the community had learned about proposals for Holsworthy Beacon and their potential impacts. The developer, Galileo Empower, is Swiss-registered, with finance from Australia and New Zealand. Stephen also discussed how small-scale local generation can be disadvantaged when it competes with large-scale energy producers.

The Beacon Energy DCO application was reported to have been withdrawn because a grid connection would not be available until at least 2037. Following the summit, KSCA noted that there was no corresponding entry on the Planning Inspectorate website or the TEC register and contacted the campaign group for further details about the withdrawal. Stephen had been encouraged to speak at the summit by his constituency MP, Sir Geoffrey Cox, who was also present.

Marc Williams from Springwell Solar Action Group described the number of proposed developments affecting his area, including Beacon Fen and Fosse Green, alongside seven further battery energy storage system (BESS) projects. Together, these proposals involve 11,000 acres of solar panels and 4,000 BESS containers.

He explained how campaign groups could participate in the examination of a Nationally Significant Infrastructure Project (NSIP). This includes encouraging as many people as possible to register as Interested Parties, attend open hearings and speak to the Examining Authority. Individuals are generally given three minutes to speak, while action groups and parish councils can have ten minutes.

Marc described how his group had worked to engage parish councils, including the need to change councillors to secure their involvement. He encouraged people to make use of the examination process to question the developer and engage with the Examining Authority. Questions and responses are documented, and contributions need not be limited to technical matters: personal experiences and emotional impacts can also be shared.

The Springwell project was approved by the Secretary of State despite having no physical grid connection. The campaign group has submitted an application for a judicial review and is awaiting a decision on whether it will proceed. If it does, the judicial review could take 8–12 months, causing further delays.

Steve Tyler from Claydens Solar Action Group in Buckinghamshire described the Rosefield Solar Farm proposal, comprising 500 MW of solar photovoltaic (PV) capacity and 500 MW of BESS. The solar project has Gate 2 grid status, while the BESS has Gate 1 status. A new substation would be needed for the connection, but National Grid Electricity Transmission (NGET) has not yet applied for planning permission for it.

Despite this, two other BESS projects have also been proposed in the area. One claims it could connect in 2026, although the existing substation cannot currently accommodate new connections.

Steve showed videos demonstrating the noise from BESS installations and the noise associated with piling solar panels into the ground, which could continue for two years or more. He described the frustration of the examination process, where details can be deferred to a later stage, and said he felt the Planning Inspectorate had shown little interest in the detail. He thanked his MP, Greg Smith, for “being a real rock”.

Several other speakers, including representatives from Hands Off Our Marsh and Stop Green Hill, also highlighted developments progressing through the planning process despite the absence of a grid connection. Some had already received development consent, raising concerns about the order in which projects were being approved.

KSCA attends Solar Action Summit at Westminster round table

Questions over costs, recycling and land use

Katherine Porter, an independent energy consultant with a PhD in physics, challenged the view that solar power is necessarily cheap. She outlined three categories of costs that she said were often overlooked.

The first was direct subsidies. Although solar may be cheaper than wholesale electricity prices, extended contracts can create additional costs in the future. A post-meeting note recorded that some legacy high-cost subsidies may be removed soon.

The second was the cost of balancing the electricity grid because solar and wind generation are intermittent. These costs can rise to £50 million a day and can be reviewed on the National Energy System Operator (NESO) website. Katherine said that BESS installations associated with solar projects can benefit financially from grid-balancing costs, increasing their profitability.

She also pointed out that solar has a capacity factor of around 10% and does not necessarily generate electricity when demand is highest, such as on winter evenings around dinner time. She questioned the contribution that solar could make to energy security at those times.

The third category was land use. Because of its relatively low efficiency and intermittent output, solar requires large areas of land to generate the same amount of electricity as a gas turbine or nuclear power station. Katherine argued that this hidden cost was not usually factored into comparisons.

Mirunalini Suthen summarised her MSc research into recycling solar PV panels, focusing on rooftop panels. Recovering individual materials, including silver and other metals, can be difficult because they are strongly bonded together to withstand outdoor conditions. The recovered materials may be of poor quality, and purification can require substantial energy. Recycling may therefore not be economically viable in every case.

As she put it, “Being recyclable in principle is not enough.” She argued that a better way to reduce waste would be to extend the working life of panels from 30 to 40 years, taking a whole-life approach to their use.

Ed Molyneux from CPRE discussed its Shout from the Rooftops research, undertaken with UCL, which explores how solar targets could be met more effectively than under current government policy. The research promotes an approach aiming for 60% of solar generation to come from rooftops, rather than the Government’s intended emphasis on ground-mounted solar. Ed also called for ground-mounted solar to be banned on Best and Most Versatile (BMV) agricultural land.

The discussion from the floor highlighted that Grade 3b land can also be highly productive and should not be overlooked when considering the impact of solar developments on agriculture.

MPs call for a collective campaign

Andrew Bowie MP, the Shadow Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, spoke about the change in his party’s approach to large-scale solar since Labour came to power. Representing an Aberdeenshire constituency affected by wind farm NSIPs, he apologised for his previous lack of understanding of the impacts on communities while in government and said he now better understood the concerns.

He challenged the Government’s push for solar on farmland and argued that energy security and food security should be given equal consideration. He also questioned whether the 2050 net zero target was attainable, describing it as arbitrary.

Andrew said: “MPs do a fantastic job in advocating for their constituent communities, and being champions for the country and beautiful landscapes”. He ended with the words, “Kemi is on our side!”

The Rt Hon Graham Stuart MP, who led the question-and-answer session, has been an MP for 21 years. He described the summit as the beginning of a major campaign or protest. He encouraged attendees to focus on influencing the people who make decisions in government, while acknowledging that changing policy can be difficult given the Government’s large majority.

He urged campaigners to lobby Labour MPs and challenge them on the impacts of proposed developments. MPs are grounded in their constituencies and need to be re-elected, he noted.

A Private Member’s Bill has been timetabled that would call for ground-mounted solar to be made illegal on BMV agricultural land.

KSCA calls for a pause in DCO applications

KSCA highlighted the further delay to the Strategic Spatial Energy Plan (SSEP), now expected in December 2027. The subsequent Central and Regional plans are expected to follow another year later.

KSCA proposed an urgent call for a pause in all ground-mounted solar DCO applications and examinations until the strategic plans are complete. The concern is that projects could receive consent now without a realistic prospect of a future grid connection, potentially creating unnecessary costs for taxpayers and communities.

The idea of a pause was welcomed by attendees, and this would have been noted by the MPs present.

Springwell Action Group also proposed writing to the Secretary of State to request the immediate publication of the six proposed SSEP pathways. The group argued that, without publication, decisions could be made behind closed doors and subsequent consultation could become meaningless. A copy of a suggested letter was circulated at the summit.

Working together to influence government

The summit highlighted the shared concerns of campaign groups dealing with large-scale ground-mounted solar proposals, including impacts on agricultural land, communities, grid connections, energy costs and the planning process.

A sign-up sheet was circulated for campaign groups wishing to join Sensible Solar, a Westminster-led lobbying campaign to develop a collective approach to putting pressure on government ministers to change policy on large-scale, ground-mounted solar developments.

KSCA signed up to take part in the campaign.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.